• Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblower Resources
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
The Truth at Any Cost.
Qui Tam, Compliance and Anti-Corruption News.
SIGN THE PETITION FOR NATIONAL WHISTLEBLOWER DAY IN 2023
Whistleblower Network News
  • Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblower Resources
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
No Result
View All Result
Home Features

What’s Wrong With The Senate Whistleblower Bill? – Part 6

Stephen KohnbyStephen Kohn
August 25, 2009
in Features, Government, Legislation, News
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInEmail

Bookmark and Share

On July 29, 2009 the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs unanimously reported out of committee S. 372, the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act of 2009.  Unfortunately, this bill contains many significant differences from the House Bill (H.R. 1507), which the National Whistleblowers Center (NWC) fully supports.  

This post is the sixth in a series of twelve, examining specific weaknesses in the Senate Bill. Each installment examines a crucial issue of whistleblower rights compromised by the Senate’s version of the bill.

VI: WILL ANY FEDERAL EMPLOYEES EVER HAVE THEIR CASE HEARD IN FEDERAL COURT?

Support Whistleblower Network News

The short answer to this question is virtually, none.

When read together, the numerous “poison pill” provisions inserted into S. 372 all but guarantee that very few, if any, federal employee cases will ever be removed to district court for a real trial.
 

As outlined in the blog postings 1, 2, 3, and 5, between the new limits on the definition of protected disclosure, the extremely narrow class of cases permitted to be filed in federal court, the 270 day rule, and the summary judgment rule, it will be virtually impossible for an employee to successfully meet the criteria established in the Senate Bill for filing a claim in federal court.

The Senate Bill does contain a provision in which a federal employee can ask the MSPB to certify their case for a federal court trial before they undergo the expensive full MSPB proceeding. See Section 117 (a)(k)(4)(A)(ii)(1) (Page 29).  However, this certification provision is a complete illusion. It requires the MSPB to admit that a case is too complex for the MSPB to handle.  It will be extremely rare for that certification to happen.  

Additionally, an employee has no practical method to appeal a ruling by the MSPB denying certification and court access.  First, such appeals cannot be immediately filed.  The employee will be forced to spend money fully litigating their case before the MSPB, and can only appeal the denial after the employee loses their case.

Second, the standard of review contained in S. 372 is the highest standard applicable in law.  Instead of a de novo review of the law or facts, the courts are required under the law to defer to the rulings of the MSPB, and can only reverse such a ruling if the decision is found to be “arbitrary, capricious or an abuse of discretion.”  This standard is almost impossible to meet.  Thus, a ruling by the MSPB denying an employee the right to file his or her claim in federal court is, for all practical purposes, unreviewable.  

President Obama promised all federal employees full access to federal court when adjudicating their whistleblower cases.  In one such statement, published on the official Obama transition team web site, the President-Elect stated:

Often the best source of information about waste, fraud, and
abuse in government is an existing government employee
committed to public integrity and willing to speak out. Such
acts of courage and patriotism, which can sometimes save lives
and often save taxpayer dollars, should be encouraged rather
than stifled. We need to empower federal employees as
watchdogs of wrongdoing and partners in performance. Barack
Obama will strengthen whistleblower laws to protect federal
workers who expose waste, fraud, and abuse of authority in
government. Obama will ensure that federal agencies expedite
the process for reviewing whistleblower claims whistleblowers
have full access to courts and due process.

S. 372, as it is currently reads, does not fulfill that promise.  It creates a false hope, and then cheats federal workers out of the rights for which they were promised and for which they need.

 

Read all the postings for What’s Wrong With The Senate Whistleblower Bill?

Tags: H.R. 1507House Committee on Oversight and Government ReformLegislationS. 372SenateSenate MarkupWhistleblower
Previous Post

What’s Wrong With The Senate Whistleblower Bill? – Part 5

Next Post

What’s Wrong With The Senate Whistleblower Bill? – Part 7

Stephen Kohn

Stephen Kohn

Next Post

What's Wrong With The Senate Whistleblower Bill? - Part 7

Please login to join discussion

Receive Daily Alerts

Subscribe to receive daily breaking news and legislative developments sent to your inbox.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Most Popular

Change the Culture, Make National Whistleblower Day Permanent

Tell President Biden to “Finish the Job” for Whistleblowers

Whistleblower Advocates See Parallels to Enron in Silicon Valley Bank Collapse

Whistleblower Jóhannes Stefánsson Plans to Testify at Fishrot Trial in Namibia

WNN Exclusive Interview with Social Security Whistleblowers Sarah Carver and Jennifer Griffith — Part 1

Whistleblower Raised Concerns of Rodents, Spiders in Kitchen of Childcare Facility, Then Fired; OSHA Rules They Were Retaliated Against

Whistleblower Poll

Whistleblower Poll
Whistleblower Poll

Exclusive Marist Poll: Overwhelming Public Support Among Likely Voters For Increased Whistleblower Protections

byGeoff Schweller
October 6, 2020

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

STAY INFORMED.
Subscribe to receive breaking whistleblower updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About Us

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Careers

Subscribe

  • Daily Mail
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • YouTube Channel

Contribute

  • Letter to the Editor
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Reprint Guidelines

Your Experience

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Help

  • The Whistleblowers Handbook
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Advertise
Whistleblower Network News

Whistleblower Network News is an independent online newspaper providing our readers with up-to-date information on whistleblowing. Our goal is to be the best source of information on important qui tam, anti-corruption, compliance, and whistleblower law developments. 

Submit an Article

Copyright © 2021, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

This Newspaper/Web Site is made available by the publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website, you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Newspaper/Web Site publisher. The Newspaper/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

SIGN THE PETITION FOR NATIONAL WHISTLEBLOWER DAY IN 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Exclusives
  • Government
    • False Claims-Qui Tam
    • Federal Employees
    • Intelligence
  • Corporate
    • CFTC & Commodities
    • Dodd-Frank
    • IRS & Tax
    • SEC & Securities
  • Features
  • Legislation
  • International
    • Foreign Corruption
  • Rewards
  • Whistleblower of the Week
  • Environment & Climate
  • Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Employment
    • Sarbanes-Oxley Whistleblowers
    • Retaliation
    • OSHA
  • Media
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • National Whistleblower Day
  • Whistleblower Poll
  • Whistleblower Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Resources for Locating An Attorney
    • The New Whistleblowers Handbook
  • National Whistleblower Day ’23

Copyright © 2020, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

Become a Whistleblower Network News Subscriber

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Subscribe to WNN

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Subscribe to WNN

Add New Playlist

Go to mobile version