• Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblower Resources
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
The Truth at Any Cost.
Qui Tam, Compliance and Anti-Corruption News.
SIGN THE PETITION FOR NATIONAL WHISTLEBLOWER DAY IN 2023
Whistleblower Network News
  • Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblower Resources
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
No Result
View All Result
Home Legislation

Summary Judgment misses the “point-counterpoint”

WNN StaffbyWNN Staff
April 21, 2009
in Legislation, News
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInEmail

In a victory for whistleblowers, and all parties who believe in civil jury trials, the federal Advisory Committee on the Rules of Civil Procedure has rejected a series of proposals that defense lawyers had advanced to modify the rules for "summary judgment."  

Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) permits judges to grant "summary judgment" when they find that there is no "genuine dispute" as to any "material fact."  All inferences from the facts are supposed to be drawn in favor of the non-moving party so that the jury can make the decision in all cases where the facts permit more than one conclusion. Whistleblower advocates, and other civil rights attorneys, have long complained that judges are abusing summary judgment by taking the boss’ word that an adverse decision was not made on account of discrimination or retaliation.  Companies can then avoid a jury trial, and get a case dismissed with an order finding they are not liable at all. Many employment and whistleblower cases are decided on appeal on the issue of whether the record supports an inference that the boss is lying to cover up discrimination.

Support Whistleblower Network News

Defense lawyers, however, were hoping they could change the rules of summary judgment so they could win even more cases.  Their major proposal would have them list all the facts they claim are "undisputed."  It would then be up to the employee’s attorney to explain, with citations to the record, how they contest each and every factual claim.  If they failed to respond to one, or if the judge found their response was not sufficiently specific, then they could lose the whole case. In districts where local rules already require "point-counterpoint," civil rights attorneys complain that the process is slanted in favor of the big defense firms who have the staff to look through voluminous records to find points that are burdensome to oppose.  The result has been that under "point-counterpoint," more cases are dismissed at summary judgment without ever getting to a jury.

Meeting today in Chicago, the federal Advisory Committee rejected this defense proposal.  Whistleblowers are indebted to the American Association for Justice (AAJ) and the National Employment Lawyers Association (NELA) for mobilizing public comment against the defense bar proposals. I am indebted to the AAJ’s John Vail for alerting me to today’s decisions.

The Advisory Committee also rejected a proposal to say that entry of summary judgment is mandatory when a judge finds there is no "genuine dispute." Currently, summary judgment is discretionary, and judges can decline to enter a summary judgment if they think a case should go to a jury.  Even though judges normally find a "genuine dispute" in cases where summary judgment is denied, defense lawyers wanted to take away a judge’s option of declining summary judgment as a matter of discretion.  Defense lawyers also wanted discovery of all communications between lawyers and their experts.  The Advisory Committee rejected this proposal to keep discovery focused on the conclusions, and not on the communications.  However, discovery will be permitted of communications of experts who are employed by one of the parties.

While civil rights and whistleblower interests will benefits from today’s decisions, a new hurdle approaches.  The Advisory Committee has scheduled a major retrospective on the civil rules.  It is scheduled for May 10-11, 2010, at Duke University. New York Judge John G. Koeltl will lead the event.  A series of papers and conferences are planned on discovery, electronic discovery, pleadings and motions, and other topics.  By opening the door to a larger revamping of civil rules, the Advisory Committee has set the stage for a new round of advocacy and public participation on what we need to preserve our civil rights.

 

 

Tags: Legislation
Previous Post

DOL’s old ARB continues to clobber whistleblowers

Next Post

Senator Grassley Expresses Support For Stronger Anti-Fraud Legislation

WNN Staff

WNN Staff

Next Post

Senator Grassley Expresses Support For Stronger Anti-Fraud Legislation

Please login to join discussion

Receive Daily Alerts

Subscribe to receive daily breaking news and legislative developments sent to your inbox.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Most Popular

U.S. and UK Advocates Come Together for Whistleblowing Awareness Week

“We want to dispel the stigma.” — Discussing the 1st Whistleblowing Awareness Week with Georgina Halford-Hall and Stephen Kohn

Tell President Biden to “Finish the Job” for Whistleblowers

Change the Culture, Make National Whistleblower Day Permanent

Senators Introduce Bipartisan Bill to Strengthen SEC Whistleblower Program

Ontario Securities Commission Highlights Success of Whistleblower Award Program

Whistleblower Poll

Whistleblower Poll
Whistleblower Poll

Exclusive Marist Poll: Overwhelming Public Support Among Likely Voters For Increased Whistleblower Protections

byGeoff Schweller
October 6, 2020

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

STAY INFORMED.
Subscribe to receive breaking whistleblower updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About Us

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Careers

Subscribe

  • Daily Mail
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • YouTube Channel

Contribute

  • Letter to the Editor
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Reprint Guidelines

Your Experience

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Help

  • The Whistleblowers Handbook
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Advertise
Whistleblower Network News

Whistleblower Network News is an independent online newspaper providing our readers with up-to-date information on whistleblowing. Our goal is to be the best source of information on important qui tam, anti-corruption, compliance, and whistleblower law developments. 

Submit an Article

Copyright © 2021, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

This Newspaper/Web Site is made available by the publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website, you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Newspaper/Web Site publisher. The Newspaper/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

SIGN THE PETITION FOR NATIONAL WHISTLEBLOWER DAY IN 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Exclusives
  • Government
    • False Claims-Qui Tam
    • Federal Employees
    • Intelligence
  • Corporate
    • CFTC & Commodities
    • Dodd-Frank
    • IRS & Tax
    • SEC & Securities
  • Features
  • Legislation
  • International
    • Foreign Corruption
  • Rewards
  • Whistleblower of the Week
  • Environment & Climate
  • Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Employment
    • Sarbanes-Oxley Whistleblowers
    • Retaliation
    • OSHA
  • Media
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • National Whistleblower Day
  • Whistleblower Poll
  • Whistleblower Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Resources for Locating An Attorney
    • The New Whistleblowers Handbook
  • National Whistleblower Day ’23

Copyright © 2020, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

Become a Whistleblower Network News Subscriber

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Subscribe to WNN

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Subscribe to WNN

Add New Playlist

Go to mobile version