• Whistleblower Voices
  • Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblowers Handbook
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
The Truth at Any Cost.
Qui Tam, Compliance and Anti-Corruption News.
Whistleblower Network News
  • Whistleblower Voices
  • Qui Tam
  • SEC
  • CFTC
  • FCPA
  • Whistleblowers Handbook
  • FAQS
Subscribe
Donate
No Result
View All Result
Whistleblower Network News
No Result
View All Result
Home Corporate

“The Garcetti Virus” and an erosion of whistleblower’s rights

WNN StaffbyWNN Staff
June 20, 2012
in Corporate, Government, News
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Share on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInEmail

In Nancy M. Modesitt’s recent research article “The Garcetti Virus,” she explains how a doctrine known as the job duties exclusion has come to erode protections once afforded to whistleblowers. She explains that this doctrine allows the discharge of an individual who discovers illegal activities while performing his or her job and then reports those issues to a supervisor. Although one might think the current whistleblower laws would protect such disclosures, Modesitt explains that is no longer the case.
Modesitt details how the the Federal Circuit created the job duties exclusion more than a decade ago in the case of Wills v. Department of Agriculture (1998). The case involved an employee in the Department of Agriculture who reported to his supervisor that a number of farms he had investigated were not complying with a government soil-protection program. The supervisor disagreed with the employee’s findings and overruled him on 6 of the 7 cases. The employee complained about the decision and later claimed that he was retaliated against for his comments. When the case was heard by the Federal Circuit, the court decided that the employees comments did not put him “at personal risk for the benefit of the public good.” As such, the court ruled that his comments could not “constitute a protected disclosure under the [Whistleblowers Protection Act (WPA)].” In later cases involving disclosures made by federal employees, the courts further limited the protection afforded to them for their whistleblower activities.

As a result of these limitations, employees involved in investigation work who then report wrongdoing within their agency are currently only protected in two situations. Those situations are “(1) where the disclosure is made outside of normal reporting channels and (2) where the disclosure is not one that is normally a part of the job.” These protections are very limited in scope and encourage employees to report wrongdoing to outside sources instead of those within their agency. By limiting the protection of employees to cases where a issue was reported to an outside source, employees are encouraged to forgo reporting instances of wrongdoing to their supervisors and, instead, speak to outside sources. This can create a feeling of distrust between employers and employees that is not conducive to a healthy work environment.
Although the job duties exclusion was once only used in cases involving federal employees, Modesitt argues that a drastic change has occurred. An increasing number of employers have, with some success, argued that the exclusion should apply to employees in both the public and private sectors. To prevent the application of this exclusion to non-federal employees, Modesitt ends her article by offering two ways in which the issue can be handled. She states that Congress should amend the WPA to protect public and private sector employees and that state level legislatures should amend the whistleblower protection statutes in their own states. By employing these two solutions, she believes that whistleblowers will be able to, once again engage, in the “legitimate reporting of unlawful activity” without limitations that too severely constrict their speech.
This blog post was written by intern Russell Haver.

Other blog entries addressing Garcetti include:

Supreme Court ducks conflict on Garcetti

Ninth Circuit protects social worker’s court testimony

ARB protects duty speech, but not investigating duties

DC federal court upholds jury verdict for fraud whistleblower

Protect Yourself: Purchase the New Whistleblower Handbook Protect Yourself: Purchase the New Whistleblower Handbook Protect Yourself: Purchase the New Whistleblower Handbook
Tags: Corporate WhistleblowersGovernment WhistleblowersLegislationWhistleblower FAQ
Previous Post

Congress Considers Granting PHS Whistleblower Protections

Next Post

IRS plans to retool its whistleblower program

WNN Staff

WNN Staff

Next Post

IRS plans to retool its whistleblower program

Write a Letter to The Editor.

Receive Daily Alerts

Subscribe to receive daily breaking news and legislative developments sent to your inbox.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Most Popular

Congressmembers Reintroduce Espionage Act Reform Act; Bill Would Bolster Protections for Journalists, Expand Reporting Options for Whistleblowers

Congressional Filing Defends SEC Whistleblower Program from Recent Attacks

Skilled Nursing and Long-Term Care Provider To Pay Over $5 Million to Settle Allegations of FCA Violations

Boston Scientific Whistleblower Alleges FCPA Violations

“I would never have believed that this sort of stuff was going on in the banking sector.” — WNN Exclusive Interview with Jeff Morris

Research Points to Gender Disparities in Whistleblower Retaliation

Whistleblower Poll

Whistleblower Poll
Whistleblower Poll

Exclusive Marist Poll: Overwhelming Public Support Among Likely Voters For Increased Whistleblower Protections

byGeoff Schweller
October 6, 2020

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

STAY INFORMED.
Subscribe to receive breaking whistleblower updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About Us

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Careers

Subscribe

  • Daily Mail
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • YouTube Channel

Contribute

  • Letter to the Editor
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Reprint Guidelines

Your Experience

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Help

  • The Whistleblowers Handbook
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Advertise
Whistleblower Network News

Whistleblower Network News is an independent online newspaper providing our readers with up-to-date information on whistleblowing. Our goal is to be the best source of information on important qui tam, anti-corruption, compliance, and whistleblower law developments. 

Submit an Article

Copyright © 2021, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

This Newspaper/Web Site is made available by the publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this website, you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Newspaper/Web Site publisher. The Newspaper/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

No Result
View All Result
  • Exclusives
  • Government
    • False Claims-Qui Tam
    • Federal Employees
    • Intelligence
  • Corporate
    • CFTC & Commodities
    • Dodd-Frank
    • IRS & Tax
    • SEC & Securities
  • Features
  • Legislation
  • International
    • Foreign Corruption
  • Rewards
  • Whistleblower of the Week
  • Environment & Climate
  • Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Employment
    • Sarbanes-Oxley Whistleblowers
    • Retaliation
    • OSHA
  • Media
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • National Whistleblower Day
  • Whistleblower Poll
  • Whistleblower Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • The New Whistleblowers Handbook
  • National Whistleblower Day ’22

Copyright © 2020, Whistleblower Network News. All Rights Reserved.

Become a Whistleblower Network News Subscriber

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Subscribe to WNN

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Subscribe to WNN
Get Whistleblower Network News Mail
Subscribe
Free Sign-up!
close-image

Add New Playlist

Go to mobile version